I've always thought that, when it was possible, it always good to have more than one priest at a parish (which is becoming a rarer possibility.) Just like one size really doesn't fit all (believe me, I would know, with my monkey legs and arms) one priest can't be to the liking of all people. I know I am not everybody's cup of tea. What person could be?
Fr. Anthony and I are pretty different. Our styles of ministry differ greatly. If our pastoral ministry were symbolized by types of restaurants, it might look like this:
There is a time and a type of person who likes fine dining and sitting around and enjoying a meal. There are other people who like take out - to grab food on the way to the next thing. If you want a very personal encounter with a priest when getting your throat blessed on St. Blaise Day, you go to Fr. Anthony, if you want your throat blessed so that you can make it out of morning Mass in time to get to dinner, you go to me.
In the end, then, when you have variety, everybody wins.