She abhors any name that makes a boy sound like a “sissy” if
for no other reason that it makes growing up with such a name difficult. She certainly would not approve of the Johnny
Cash song, “A boy named Sue.” Reginald
and Percy are certainly not acceptable names for a boy in the United States
though, “they are suitable for English boys.”
Perhaps Mrs. Fenner is not so found of the English. I think the English perfectly respectable
people.
When my first sister was born they thought it was going to
be me (they would have to wait another 16 years) and my Dad wanted to name me Christopher
because of a highly popular nickname at the time for this name was “Kit” that
my Dad thought was of some snappy value for some reason. I think both Mrs. Fenner and Monsignor
Manners would not have approved.
Fortunately the nickname was out of fashion by 1965.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/09bb9/09bb90f6b17d321f5c821e3cff63292b59853e0b" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/613a2/613a2d440ed60edc2b858f26094b4d179728e878" alt=""
Now: Syllables! Like
poetry, one must be careful with the number of syllables in your child’s
name. (I told you it was going to get
harder.) “Do not use three one syllable
or three two syllable names for your child,” Mrs. Fenner suggests. “There is nothing wrong with these names but
when said together they sound like soldiers clumping along with heavy boots!” Which may be exactly what you want when he is
in trouble! Imagine standing on your
back porch and calling out, “John George Smith!
Get in here right now!”
“It is better to be trite than pretentious,” reports Mrs.
Fenner, “but avoid both.” She also
recommends avoiding picking fashionable names.
Like good architecture, classical is always in fashion. Fashionable always runs the high risk of
dating oneself and eventually sounding trite.
“Bambie? What an adorable name! Let me guess when you were born.”
Then there is a the problem of too many of the same consonants
or too many of the same vowel sounds.
She does not explain why but you can guess why a child with the name, “Lilly
Loraine Little” might feel like the Littl’ ole’ Lady from Littl’ Italy. I think my parents did quite well with “John
Anthony Valencheck.”